Why can't we just celebrate the fact that Google built something new instead of beat it to death with criticisms of how it isn't perfect or a game changer, etc?
I like new tech and new products to play with, whether they come from YC, Google, or the hacker down the street.
There's room in town for more than one, and everybody you ask will have their own favourite.
All it takes is one tweak of an algorithm or a prolonged outage to put you out of business.