This is straw-man stuff based on an old view of who uses Java and when.

I've programmed in a lot of languages - C++, Java, Objective-C (with a NeXT, of course) and the trendier functional, meta-programming languages.

One of the cliches (and truisms) of C++ is that you only use a subset. This is what people are doing with Java these days. You can bring up high-performance web services using only a thin layer of J2EE and throw away all that cruft you mention. In my company we do it all with a third-party web layer and just SE (is it just J2EE you're agin - are you fine with SE?).

What Java brings to the table is a well-sorted high performance JVM, copious free and high-quality third-party libraries and a clear and easy to use syntax. Yea, it's quite verbose, but, as you know, you spend more time reading code than writing it...