undefined | Better HN

0 pointstomp11y ago0 comments

You can't compare being a teacher with a career in "law, medicine, politics, or finance" or a programmer. The latter all require very high intellectual aptitude, either logical/mathematical (programming, finance), memory (medicine, law) or social intelligence (finance, politics). In contrast, mostly everybody can be a teacher (and according to comment [1], teachers usually come from the bottom of their class).

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9090437

0 comments

tptacek11y ago

Perhaps 20 years ago it was the case that anyone could get job as a teacher. That's very difficult from succeeding as a teacher, and it's also not true today.

BSousa11y ago

Like anyone can be a lawyers or a programmer. There are good and bad ones, and a good teacher will require a lot of skills and 'logical' aptitude as well as empathy. AFAIK, you can't take a 4 week bootcamp and teach high-school math, but you can get a job at a startup after a rails bootcamp.

Can we stop with the 'we are so special/intelligent' arrogance?

frabcus11y ago

This isn't true - the core skill of controlling classes is pretty hard. It's not an intellectual skill, but a social intelligence one.

tompOP11y ago

The difference is that you only see you're bad at it when you're already a teacher, teaching a class. If you suck at programming, you see it in the introductory course of first semester of college.

ameister1411y ago

You don't have to be that smart to be a programmer, and it takes less schooling than being a teacher requires.

tompOP11y ago

Maybe not smart, but you have to have the ability to do a certain kind of abstract thinking. Like translating concepts into sequences of very precise steps (i.e. algorithms).

1 more reply

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse

0 pointstomp11y ago0 comments

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9090437

0 comments

tptacek11y ago

Perhaps 20 years ago it was the case that anyone could get job as a teacher. That's very difficult from succeeding as a teacher, and it's also not true today.

BSousa11y ago

Can we stop with the 'we are so special/intelligent' arrogance?

frabcus11y ago

This isn't true - the core skill of controlling classes is pretty hard. It's not an intellectual skill, but a social intelligence one.

tompOP11y ago

The difference is that you only see you're bad at it when you're already a teacher, teaching a class. If you suck at programming, you see it in the introductory course of first semester of college.

ameister1411y ago

You don't have to be that smart to be a programmer, and it takes less schooling than being a teacher requires.

tompOP11y ago

Maybe not smart, but you have to have the ability to do a certain kind of abstract thinking. Like translating concepts into sequences of very precise steps (i.e. algorithms).

1 more reply

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse