undefined | Better HN

0 pointsrapind11y ago0 comments

As an example that I deal with daily, writing React components in CoffeeScript v.s. Javascript really highlights the elegance of CoffeeScript.

Of course you can reduce the JS verbosity with JSX instead... which again is introducing a pre-processor to the mix (one I personally am not a fan of, but w/e).

ES6 adds some sweet stuff for sure, but IMO it doesn't make JS a pleasure to work with yet (which seems to be the argument?).

I'm willing to bet it's not going to reduce the count in this list by much. https://github.com/jashkenas/coffeescript/wiki/list-of-langu...

I'm comfortable writing either as I'm sure many are, but when given the choice I opt for CoffeeScript.

P.S. Good luck telling someone using ClojureScript that they should switch back to Javascript.

0 comments

colin_jack11y ago

"it doesn't make JS a pleasure to work with yet (which seems to be the argument?)"

My interpretation of what Retozi is saying is that CS just means that in addition to understanding JS, including ES6, you need to be familiar with all the different ways things can be done in CS.

I tend to agree, especially as JS is becoming an improving with each release.

What I'd like to see going forward is JS continuing to add selective sugar as is in CS, but also add functionality that makes going into a new fresh JS codebase and making sense of it easier. That side of things is less about CS, and more about the sorts of ideas you see in Dart and TypeScript.

rapindOP11y ago

My experience is the exact opposite. I find that CS removes a lot of the JS gotchas, and I'm not clear on the many ways that CS let's you do something, especially in comparison to JS. If anything it protects you a bit, by trying to enforce some of the "good parts".

http://arcturo.github.io/library/coffeescript/07_the_bad_par...

To each his own, but to me CS has been and continues to be a complete and obvious win over JS. 9 times out of 10 the benefit outweighs the annoyance of requiring a preprocessor for me.

colin_jack11y ago

On the multiple ways, I was sure I read a post that documented them all and had me nodding along but can't find it, this one seems good though [1].

[1] http://ceronman.com/2012/09/17/coffeescript-less-typing-bad-...

1 more reply

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse

0 pointsrapind11y ago0 comments

As an example that I deal with daily, writing React components in CoffeeScript v.s. Javascript really highlights the elegance of CoffeeScript.

Of course you can reduce the JS verbosity with JSX instead... which again is introducing a pre-processor to the mix (one I personally am not a fan of, but w/e).

ES6 adds some sweet stuff for sure, but IMO it doesn't make JS a pleasure to work with yet (which seems to be the argument?).

I'm willing to bet it's not going to reduce the count in this list by much. https://github.com/jashkenas/coffeescript/wiki/list-of-langu...

I'm comfortable writing either as I'm sure many are, but when given the choice I opt for CoffeeScript.

P.S. Good luck telling someone using ClojureScript that they should switch back to Javascript.

0 comments

colin_jack11y ago

"it doesn't make JS a pleasure to work with yet (which seems to be the argument?)"

My interpretation of what Retozi is saying is that CS just means that in addition to understanding JS, including ES6, you need to be familiar with all the different ways things can be done in CS.

I tend to agree, especially as JS is becoming an improving with each release.

rapindOP11y ago

http://arcturo.github.io/library/coffeescript/07_the_bad_par...

To each his own, but to me CS has been and continues to be a complete and obvious win over JS. 9 times out of 10 the benefit outweighs the annoyance of requiring a preprocessor for me.

colin_jack11y ago

On the multiple ways, I was sure I read a post that documented them all and had me nodding along but can't find it, this one seems good though [1].

[1] http://ceronman.com/2012/09/17/coffeescript-less-typing-bad-...

1 more reply

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse