undefined | Better HN

0 pointsdanso11y ago0 comments

OK, I see that the flaw was that the phone number was revealed to a user when, after installing the Twitter for iPhone app, wanted to specify that the code be sent via text to a phone number...And the Twitter app reminds the user -- who again, has successfully entered the password -- what number the message goes to.

So, if you're thinking, what kind of dumbass would need to be reminded what phone the code was going to?...well, the OP for starters. In fact, he recommends readers to get Google Voice numbers (ooh, another attack vector/dependency, but let's ignore that for now)...so, if you're such a user, who has a phone and some burner numbers, and you tell the Twitter app to send a reminder to your phone number...and nothing comes...that's going to seem like a point of failure.

And IMO, that situation is going to be much more likely than the case of a user telling the world his password and username. Also, it seems more likely than phishers doing something more damaging than getting phone numbers after manually going through the phone app for each password stolen...My impression is that such phishers do not typically rely on manual methods, especially if by doing so, they don't get access to the target account...seems like a low return on investment of effort.

0 comments

x1798DE11y ago

The threat model isn't "what if someone tells everyone their username and password", it's "What if someone gets your username and password". I think most of the time people have one number they connect to, and everything else will be fringe cases. If you're worried they'll forget what phone number it's sent to, you can do the same thing you do with other verification/reset loops - "Enter your e-mail address and we'll send you an e-mail with the phone number you used". It might not always be the best authentication method, but at this point almost all authentication falls back to "I control the e-mail address that I controlled when I started the account" at this point anyway.

Plus, at the very least you could just reveal the last 2 digits of the phone number upon request. That's still side-channel data leakage, but at least it's much more contained.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse

0 pointsdanso11y ago0 comments

0 comments

x1798DE11y ago

Plus, at the very least you could just reveal the last 2 digits of the phone number upon request. That's still side-channel data leakage, but at least it's much more contained.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse