undefined | Better HN

0 pointsbarrkel11y ago0 comments

But Nanex appears to be showing people responding to orders after they hit the exchanges, and that would seem to be legal and moral.

It's legal, yes, but you can't make a jump to moral so easily.

I don't think it's necessarily immoral either, but morality depends on much more - what the end results are, who is affected, what kind of effect, etc. Morality doesn't exist in the vacuum of an isolated decision.

0 comments

Lazare11y ago

Very true! But the reverse is also true: Critics need to show that something immoral is going on. Nanex's analysis does not, to my eye, even try and make this case.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse

0 pointsbarrkel11y ago0 comments

But Nanex appears to be showing people responding to orders after they hit the exchanges, and that would seem to be legal and moral.

It's legal, yes, but you can't make a jump to moral so easily.

0 comments

Lazare11y ago

Very true! But the reverse is also true: Critics need to show that something immoral is going on. Nanex's analysis does not, to my eye, even try and make this case.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse