undefined | Better HN

0 pointsenscr11y ago0 comments

You've used correct logic but you missed the point OP was trying to convey.

0 comments

What did I miss? OP is arguing that we should wash our behinds for the same reason that we wash our hands. Yet the reason we wash our hands is to reduce a threat that does not exist (at least, not as readily) for our behinds.

And now semantic satiation has kicked in for "behind."

hueving11y ago

>What did I miss? OP is arguing that we should wash our behinds for the same reason that we wash our hands.

No. OP is not arguing that. OP is arguing that if you got mud on your hand and tried to clean it with dry paper, there will still be crusted mud on your hand. Do you see where this is going now?

baddox11y ago

OP simply doesn't say that. OP refers to the actual common act of washing hands after using the toilet, not the hypothetical act of washing hands after getting "mud" on them.

enscrOP11y ago

I think OP meant that washing is good for personal hygiene i.e. not carrying pathogens smeared around on your skin/clothes.

baddox11y ago

That's a valid point, but not one that directly supports the argument for bidets. Since most people (at least in my neck of the woods) shower at least once a day, personal hygiene is usually accomplished.

pantalaimon11y ago

But to prove that claim OP would have to show that people who just wipe their asses are more often sick than those who wash it each time.

1 more reply

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse

0 comments

baddox11y ago

And now semantic satiation has kicked in for "behind."

hueving11y ago

>What did I miss? OP is arguing that we should wash our behinds for the same reason that we wash our hands.

No. OP is not arguing that. OP is arguing that if you got mud on your hand and tried to clean it with dry paper, there will still be crusted mud on your hand. Do you see where this is going now?

baddox11y ago

OP simply doesn't say that. OP refers to the actual common act of washing hands after using the toilet, not the hypothetical act of washing hands after getting "mud" on them.

enscrOP11y ago

I think OP meant that washing is good for personal hygiene i.e. not carrying pathogens smeared around on your skin/clothes.

baddox11y ago

pantalaimon11y ago

But to prove that claim OP would have to show that people who just wipe their asses are more often sick than those who wash it each time.

1 more reply

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse