undefined | Better HN

0 pointsceejayoz12y ago0 comments

What's wrong with encrypted Jabber?

0 comments

3 comments · 1 top-level

m_mueller12y ago· 2 in thread

On OSX I'm happy with Adium, but last time I've used Pidgin it was a lot of work to configure it the way I want. That would still work for me, but to roll it out for an organization it would meet quite some resistance. So the problem with XMPP for me is the client situation.

pgeorgi12y ago

> So the problem with XMPP for me is the client situation

... which is fixed by a better client. That requires skills, but different ones from designing a new crypto protocol.

Given the PR efforts of the telegram people, they might actually be better XMPP+OTR+TextSecure+... client implementers than crypto designers (and maybe even better client implementers than most of the people who build clients right now since the situation _is_ bad).

m_mueller12y ago

I agree with that. Why they didn't go with this route is something I'd like to know as well - Telegram's FAQ is quite vague on this issue. But still, I prefer a reasonably secure service with great clients on all platforms, over a perfectly secure service with ugly clients that I can never 'sell' to decision makers.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse