undefined | Better HN

0 pointsdwaltrip12y ago0 comments

Yeah definitely more difficult, but it depends on the storage mechanism. But I suppose even if you simply had a private key hidden in some random folder or written down somewhere (there are more secure ways - one is breaking a key into multiple parts and spreading to separate people), it would be hard to locate or identify.

0 comments

synchronise12y ago

It also depends on what possible legal action those parties might have taken against them for not complying with a disclosure request on those funds.

CoreSet12y ago

So basically: "we can't find your money so you're going to jail unless you find it for us?"

I was talking to a friend about encryption the other day and that was his salient point. Unbreakable key? Break it or go to jail.

qq6612y ago

"Break it or go to jail" is already established law that pre-dates computers ("open this combination safe or go to jail"), but courts have generally held that this law also applies to encryption keys.

1 more reply

lucb1e12y ago

Physical security is an integral part of information security. But if governments start doing things like that, what kind of country are we living in?

1 more reply

Lazare12y ago

As always, relevant XKCD: http://xkcd.com/538/

CoreSet12y ago

I suppose the bitcoin ethos of a decentralized network - with no single vulnerable point of attack - breaks down once you consider that until you can buy groceries, pay rent, and just generally use the currency everywhere, there's always the last point of vulnerability: wherever you convert it to "actual" money.

But maybe that's an unfair assessment.

dwaltripOP12y ago

For a non-governmental currency that hasn't yet had its 5th birthday, I think bitcoin is doing decently well in terms of merchant acceptance. My personal opinion is that broad merchant acceptance will only come after it is widely used for investment/asset protection (if ever, of course). One indication for this idea is the magnitude by which forex volumes dwarf actual GDP. But it's all speculation :)

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse

0 comments

synchronise12y ago

It also depends on what possible legal action those parties might have taken against them for not complying with a disclosure request on those funds.

CoreSet12y ago

So basically: "we can't find your money so you're going to jail unless you find it for us?"

I was talking to a friend about encryption the other day and that was his salient point. Unbreakable key? Break it or go to jail.

qq6612y ago

1 more reply

lucb1e12y ago

Physical security is an integral part of information security. But if governments start doing things like that, what kind of country are we living in?

1 more reply

Lazare12y ago

As always, relevant XKCD: http://xkcd.com/538/

CoreSet12y ago

But maybe that's an unfair assessment.

dwaltripOP12y ago

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse