undefined | Better HN

0 pointsAndrew_Quentin13y ago0 comments

Well, the government could make undeclared cash illegal.

0 comments

4 comments · 1 top-level

StavrosK13y ago· 3 in thread

It might even work, if they had a way to track all your cash. Unfortunately, unlike with Bitcoin, they don't. This is pretty much what I said in my original comment?

I don't understand all the apologism, it's pretty clear that governments can exert an unprecedented amount of control on money with Bitcoin (all your transactions are public), and no amount of burying our heads in the sand will change that.

Andrew_QuentinOP13y ago

But, they don't have a way to track your bitcoins. They can see how much is in each address, but they do not know whose address it is, etc.

You said the government would need to make all wallets that are not registered with some central authority illegal. That would be the same as you paying someone in cash if cash was made illegal. You would be doing something illegal in both situations. However, what is the government going to do about it if they do not know who you are?

Not to mention that making cash illegal would be a highly political issue and quite unpopular due to concerns with privacy, etc. The same would apply if the government wished to request some centrally controlled management of people's bitcoin account.

StavrosK13y ago

Sure, but in the bitcoin case, you'd require both parties' wallets to be unregistered. It would require a legal and an illegal network of wallets (since the government can't track the illegal ones), but whenever a transaction was made where one of the two parties was an illegal wallet, the legal party would be on the hook for it (as it would be transacting with an illegal wallet).

moe13y ago

I don't understand all the apologism

I would recommend to familiarize yourself with how bitcoin works on a technical level before mowing down more strawmen.

Also: Do you really think all countries of the world will agree on one central 'bitcoin address registry'? Contrary to popular belief the internet does not end at Virginia beach...

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse