undefined | Better HN

0 pointsAUmrysh13y ago0 comments

Kinetic Bombardment has been a sci-fi concept for decades, and it's interesting to see a real, possibly cost effective, technology that could make it real. At those speeds, you don't need explosives, just a lot of mass to slam into something.

0 comments

5 comments · 1 top-level

Zarathust13y ago· 4 in thread

According to project Thor, it would not be that cost efficient. The wikipedia page states that the rods would need to be at around 8 tons. A ton of tungsten is around 50k$ so 8 tons is rather negligible. What is very expensive is to get 8 tons of material to space. During the space shuttles era, bringing a kilogram of matter to space would cost around 20k$. A ton is 907 kilograms.

8 x 907 x 20 000 = 145M$ per payload.

I don't have the exact numbers for the cost of an ICMB with a nuclear warhead but I'm pretty sure that it is less than that. We also didn't factor in the cost of maintaining an orbital launcher, possibly manning that thing and other costs which being in space incur.

Maybe with newer launch methods bringing goods to space will be cheaper, but I don't think we'll see this kind of tech unless costs decrease to around 2000$/kg to space (1/10th of what it is now).

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kinetic_bombardment

hdevalence13y ago

> As of March 2013, Falcon Heavy launch costs are below $1,000 per pound ($2,200/kg) to low-Earth orbit when the launch vehicle is transporting its maximum delivered cargo weight.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Falcon_Heavy

xyzzy12313y ago

Silly question, but would it be cheaper to bring mass from space?

duaneb13y ago

Well we are reaching an age (of asteroid mining) where it's probably more cost efficient to manufacture in space and ship (or railgun, I guess) the mass to earth. Probably not for a while, but I don't think it's science fiction anymore.

AUmryshOP13y ago

That gives me an interesting idea. Do you think it could be feasible to mine ore from space and then drop-ship it to some low-depth (a few hundred feet at most) part of the ocean? The heat from re-entry would likely turn the metal into a molten blob, and the sea water would rapidly cool it.

1 more reply

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse