undefined | Better HN

0 pointsEwanToo13y ago0 comments

Star Wars Episode 1 and 2 contain exact characters and other creative designs from Episode 4/5/6.

Not "like" them, not derivative of them, but actually them (e.g. Yoda).

So yeah, that would be a direct copy.

0 comments

It would actually be a derivative of ep VI, since the characters and creative designs differ and precede it.

A direct copy, would be the _exact_same_ characters as depicted in ep VI, but alas they are not, they are however similar to, which makes it a derivative of.

jerf13y ago

Judges, the people who arbitrate copyright disputes in the end, are humans, not computer programs. I don't think that if you tried to rip off Yoda, but made slight alterations to his face wrinkles, that you're going to convince a judge that it's something other than Yoda. A judge is not going to see Yoda as anything other than the same character through all six movies, no matter how many differences between the 3D model in the Phantom Menace and the 3D model in Attack of the Clones a "diff" command might find.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse