undefined | Better HN

0 pointsjiggy201113y ago0 comments

Well, saying that might sound like you are suggesting you don't know what you are doing. Besides it's unlikely that you are going to get meaningful feedback based on one chunk of code without the context of all the other stuff it interacts with.

If that level of peer review is really important to you , then you would be best off releasing the source to your entire app.

0 comments

2 comments · 1 top-level

AlexanderZ13y ago· 1 in thread

Have you been following all the Ruby discussions in the past few days? A single action from a complex controller in Basecamp would be enough for me to understand how 37 Signals are handling the not so skinny controller stuff.

It would be much more useful than seeing another 'create user and send email' stuff, which I see in almost every article about controllers.

jiggy2011OP13y ago

Not really, but I don't think seeing a bunch of code with calls to hidden function would be all that useful.

It is simple enough to distill your approach down into some fictional code that can be easily understood. I do it all the time when I'm posting questions on Stack Overflow and don't want to stick the real code on there.

It might be nice to see some of their production code, but it doesn't really offer any value to them other than being able to fire a shot in an internet war.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse