undefined | Better HN

0 pointsceol13y ago0 comments

Like others have said, this is in no way a replacement for a pedal-powered generator, nor is it a replacement for a standing lamp. It's for folks in developing countries who would gladly trade lifting a pound or two of weight for 30 minutes of dim light.

Be cynical about the math, sure, but if the math works, don't assume technology is useless because it doesn't have a place in a 25 year old's San Francisco apartment.

0 comments

2 comments · 1 top-level

ars13y ago· 1 in thread

A pound of two? We are talking about 50 pounds, every 30 minutes, for very dim lighting.

It's not being cynical to say "It doesn't work". Cynical would be to dismiss it without even checking. We gave it a full consideration, ran the numbers, and realized: It doesn't, and Can not, work.

pdonis13y ago

It doesn't, and Can not, work.

The numbers don't show that; that's your subjective judgment based on the numbers. But the judgment that matters is not yours, but that of the potential users. It's up to them to decide whether this is better for them than a kerosene lamp.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse