undefined | Better HN

0 pointspkal22d ago0 comments

I am familiar with the syntax, so I am biased ("*/3" and "12,14,20" makes sense if you are familiar with Unix tools), but it is still more intuitive to me than the systemd unit file syntax and usage. I know that I just have to edit /etc/cron or throw any executable file into /etc/cron.d/monthly and it will work on my system, but I cannot write a systemd timer file from scratch without looking it, and to do that I first have to find the directory where the other examples are located. /etc/systemd doesn't appear to be it.

This is generally my only real complaint about systemd. I don't care if it is too monolitic, written in C or whatever, I just want a straightforward syntax for straightforward operations. I'd like it if systemd could recognize if a .target file is a shell script and just do "the right thing". Perhaps it would make sense for a timer file to recognize cron syntax as well. Or at least allow for a kind of extensibility so that I can have it supported.

If systemd had a little more respect for existing conventions, I am pretty sure it wouldn't be so controversial. After all, system administrators like it because they use it all the time, but a regular, full-timer user like me, who only deals with it when something is broken or have to use it as a means-to-an-end to set something up, then all friction is annoying and bad UX. (And no, using Nix is not the solution)

0 comments

6 comments · 2 top-level

LaSombra22d ago· 2 in thread

If you want to create a new systemd unit file you can run:

   $ sudo systemctl edit --force --full my-scheduled-work@.timer

   $ systemctl edit --user --force --full my-scheduled-work@.timer

Fire-Dragon-DoL22d ago

Why the @?

tpmoney22d ago

Systemd lets you create templates that take an argument in from the scheduled service. It gets that from the value after the @. So you can write a unit file that schedules a task to run say every 3 days and in that unit file reference `jobs/%i`, then put your task in a file in jobs and say `systemctl start every-3-days@script1.sh` to run `script1.sh` on your schedule without needing to create a new unit file for each script. StepCA has a nice write up on their site about using these templates to schedule cert renewals for any arbitrary service

1 more reply

krunck22d ago· 2 in thread

Yeah, it would be nice to have a folder like /etc/systemd-jobs/ where I could put them and where there are no files unrelated to job scheduling. There is /etc/systemd/user, but it does get a bit of pollution depending on the system.

ralferoo22d ago

Not sure if you're talking about cron or systemd, but cron definitely has that in /etc/cron.d where you can have arbitrary crontabs, or /etc/cron.{hourly|daily|weekly|monthly} where you can just place arbitrary scripts if you don't care exactly when they run, just the frequency.

weaksauce22d ago

you can organize them however you want on your system and then use symlinks to make them available.

there's also `systemctl --all list-timers` to view them.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse