undefined | Better HN

0 pointserkat12h ago0 comments

If experienced (in open source and corporate politics) developers would bet on Polymarket if the rewrite is going to be ultimately merged, which side would you bet on?

What would the emerging odds be? My guess is 19/20 in favor of ditching Zig.

I have followed many initial denials on a wide range of topics, not only rewrites, over the years. Like clockwork, most of them were lies.

0 comments

geysersam5h ago

I don't think there's much chance it gets merged.

Even if it passed the full test suite there are a ton of software qualities that are not captured by tests and I think it's unlikely the AI made the right trade-off in every such case.

* We haven't seen the benchmarks yet.

* It hasn't seen wide usage. Zig Bun has had tons of bugs ironed out, Rust Bun has a different set of bugs to iron out.

* The developers know the zig codebase well, they don't know the rust code base.

christopherwxyz12h ago

I don't think most serious developers have time to watch prediction markets.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse