undefined | Better HN

0 pointssiren20261mo ago0 comments

I think what we are arguing is that yes management layers always existed.

But the state right now is that:

- those management layers are now more disconnected than ever from the actual work. Most managers are career managers that have given up on any actual technical work. Even if they used to be technical ICs, most bigtech actively discourage managers to do anything remotely technical. I still cannot understand this.

- There are way more managers per IC than there ever was (Last big tech I was in, my org had ~5 ICs per manager. I couldn't believe it and have no idea what those people actually did the whole day besides meeting each other!). This is directly because Directors decide to hire Managers and have a direct incentive to grow the amount of layers and amount of people in their pyramid. Even if they don't mean to, directors and VPs are managers as well and as such they have a direct belief and incentive that more management is better.

0 comments

2 comments · 1 top-level

dahart1mo ago· 1 in thread

No, I think this still this isn’t an accurate framing of history. Managers have always had a completely different job than the people they manage. If anything, having a lot of managers that are in the trenches, writing code for example, is the newer trend. Since the Industrial Revolution, managers typically oversaw work but did not do the labor. You could ask some managers what they do all day, but once you get some management experience, you will start to understand what managers do all day and how there’s enough to do that getting technical work done is relatively difficult, and might compromise their ability to manage well.

Here are some pointers to the evolution of management over time that you might find interesting or enlightening:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Henri_Fayol#Functions_of_manag...

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scientific_management

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hawthorne_effect

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peter_Drucker

The typical ratio of managers to laborers has definitely increased over time. 1:5 is higher than average, but 1:10 is very common for knowledge work. There are many reasons why this is, team building incentives are only one of many. But one question you should ask yourself is why you even care. Companies are free to function any way they want to, and they pay you to contribute to their choice of structure. Given that all modern large companies function this way, and also make money, maybe it’s worth starting from the assumption that it evolved this way for a reason? See Chesterton’s Fence.

siren2026OP1mo ago

>> Since the Industrial Revolution, managers typically oversaw work but did not do the labor. You could ask some managers what they do all day, but once you get some management experience, you will start to understand what managers do all day and how there’s enough to do that getting technical work done is relatively difficult, and might compromise their ability to manage well.

Oh believe me. I have managed a lot over my career. Sometime as a TLM and a couple times as a full time manager. I was still as technical and did as much as most people on my team though, which is against what most bigTech companies would consider acceptable for a manager.

All my opinions come from everything I saw and lived during my time as a manager.

I will repeat it again: I'm sure you are not slacking as a manager, most managers I worked with did not slack either. It is simply an artificial function with self-fulfilled busywork. The reason it still exists today is that the managerial class holds the power in most companies and self-hire each other as a way to keep themselves relevant.

A ton has been written about this, so I will put some links:

"Yet for all its dysfunction, the professional-managerial system proved remarkably durable. It persisted because it solved a different problem than organizational effectiveness: it provided a way to allocate status and opportunity that appeared meritocratic while actually favoring those who could navigate institutional prestige hierarchies."

https://eyeofthesquid.com/the-last-days-of-the-managerial-cl...

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Professional%E2%80%93manageria...

1 more reply

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse

0 comments