undefined | Better HN

0 pointslukasgraf1mo ago0 comments

I can't remember the exact phrasing, but are you talking about the error message that essentially says: "The Tardis is broken. Your backup has diverged into an entirely separate timeline, and I have no way of reconciling it. You may now sacrifice an entire weekend to do an initial backup again."?

I've been on a lucky streak for several years now, where I haven't gotten that one on any of my devices.

"Preparing backup..." taking an unreasonable amount of time is a regular occurrence, and some edge cases around adjusting TM backup size quotas aren't handled well. But other than that, TM has been working reasonably well for me to back up 10 TB over SMB to a Synology NAS.

My gripe is much more with Apple's abysmal support for SMB and NFS, especially after deprecating AFP. I've been back and forth between them over the years and over several OS versions, and their implementations for both are just terrible.

But over time SMB, for me, proved slightly more stable and performant, with the right tweaks in smb.conf, and authentication and permissions/ownership are easier to deal with than NFS, so I stuck with that.

I also yearn for the days where TM just worked, because somehow, the alternatives are even worse:

- Arq Backup does some things quite well, which is why I use it as part of my 3-2-1. But some of its bugs and implementation decisions just scream "hobby grade" to me.

- Kopia looks interesting, but it's not mature enough yet. Failed for me with absolutely cryptic error messages during repo init both times I tried it, with versions several months apart.

- Restic, Borg / Vorta: Not turnkey enough for me.

0 comments

3 comments · 1 top-level

TexanFeller1mo ago· 2 in thread

> "Preparing backup..." taking an unreasonable amount of time is a regular occurrence,

TM heavily throttles disk I/O used for backing up in order to ensure that normal user activity isn't affected. That makes it appear that TM is dramatically slower than you would expect which greatly annoys me. This becomes obvious after you run this command which will make both the preparing and transferring phases go closer to the theoretical speed you'd expect:

sudo sysctl debug.lowpri_throttle_enabled=0

lukasgrafOP1mo ago

> TM heavily throttles disk I/O used for backing up

That makes sense, and I usually quite like that behavior. I barely ever notice an impact when backups are running.

However, this is happening every time on one machine (Intel iMac), and semi-regularly on another one (M3 MBP), after a fresh restart, giving mds_stores some time to settle down, and the most recent backup just hours ago, with no significant changes on disk since.

In a situation like that, I would expect the "Preparing backup..." stage to just take a second to create an APFS snapshot, and maybe a minute to diff that snapshot against the remote state. But not 10+ minutes.

But thank you for the hint about that sysctl parameter! I will certainly give this a try.

p_ing1mo ago

TM makes my M2 Air chug when it runs against a local Samsung SSD. It does no such I/O throttling.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse