undefined | Better HN

0 pointsbundy13y ago0 comments

hey a1k0n, we'll definitely have to take a look at the port you dropped in your post. we didn't do a ton of research before hand, but we were debating between box2djs and box2dweb. in the end we choose box2dweb since it's self contained within a single file and was supposed to be more up to date.

i don't think what you're saying is totally off topic. box2d is pretty awesome and it's surprisingly easy to get physics simulations up and running using the library.

0 comments

a1k0n13y ago

The thing about the emscripten version is that their own demos seem to GC-pause constantly on Chrome. I'm assuming the emscripten-generated code is making tons of incidental garbage, but I haven't profiled it or anything; it's all Closure-compiled and impossible to read. I'm still using the old old old actionscript port of the old version, and wish I had seen box2dweb sooner.

btw disasteroids is hilariously awesome. Great work.

kevingadd13y ago

Emscripten generally speaking does not produce garbage because it uses a virtual heap. If you profile the demos using a heap profiler like Chrome's you will be able to observe this. The pauses are likely due to bugs in V8 that cause it to recompile a page's JavaScript constantly (it has a lot of them). The cost of those bugs ends up being higher than that of equivalent bugs in Firefox's JS engine because of the way V8 is designed.

Either way, though, if you have a reproduction case for those pauses you should definitely file a bug about it on the appropriate tracker - emscripten's if something is wrong with the generated code, or chromium's.

a1k0n13y ago

Yeah -- I knew about the virtual heap arrays, so the GC explanation didn't make sense. I'll dig into it; thanks for the pointers.

I think you're right though. Once it's been running a while, it seems OK; so I think it was JIT compilation pauses.

1 more reply

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse

0 pointsbundy13y ago0 comments

i don't think what you're saying is totally off topic. box2d is pretty awesome and it's surprisingly easy to get physics simulations up and running using the library.

0 comments

a1k0n13y ago

btw disasteroids is hilariously awesome. Great work.

kevingadd13y ago

a1k0n13y ago

Yeah -- I knew about the virtual heap arrays, so the GC explanation didn't make sense. I'll dig into it; thanks for the pointers.

I think you're right though. Once it's been running a while, it seems OK; so I think it was JIT compilation pauses.

1 more reply

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse