undefined | Better HN

0 pointsCyph0n18d ago0 comments

Just to echo what others are saying: NixOS and Proxmox are the answer.

I run both right now, but I am in the process of just running NixOS on everything.

NixOS really is that good, particularly for homelabs. The module system and ability to share them across machines is really a superpower. You end up having a base config that all machines extend essentially. Same idea applies to users and groups.

One of the other big benefits, particularly for homelabs, is that your config is effectively self-documenting. Every quirk you discover is persisted in a source controlled file. Upgrades are self-documenting too: upstream module maintainers are pretty good about guiding you towards the new way to do things via option and module deprecation.

0 comments

WestCoader18d ago

I mean this in a good way, but I'm slightly chuckling to myself that it reads like people are just discovering IaC...on HN. That's all Nix configs are, at the end of the day.

No matter the tool, manage your environment in code, your life becomes much easier. People start and then get addicted to the ClickOps for the initial hit and then end up in a packed closet with a one way ticket to Narnia.

This happens in large environments too, so not at all just a home lab thing.

Cyph0nOP18d ago

I and many other NixOS users know what IaC is :)

A NixOS config is a bit different because it’s lower level and is configuring the OS through a first-party interface. It is more like extending the distro itself as opposed to configuring an existing distro after the fact.

The other big difference is that it is purely declarative vs. a simulation of a declarative config a la Ansible and other tools. Again, because the distro is config aware at all levels, starting from early boot.

The last difference is atomicity. You can (in theory) rely on an all or nothing config switch as well as the ability to rollback at any time (even at boot).

On top of all this are the niceties enabled by Nix and nixpkgs. Shared binary caches, run a config on a VM, bake a live ISO or cloud VM image from a config (Packer style), the NixOS test framework, etc.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse