Ask HN: How do you respond to blog posts that seem AI assisted?

1 pointscyndunlop19d ago3 comments

When you hit an article that smells like AI, do you immediately click away? Hold your nose and keep reading if the topic is interesting? Take note of the author and never read their work again? Would it matter if a human authored it in another language then AI translated to English?

Please share in this survey (https://docs.google.com/forms/d/e/1FAIpQLSfNweiNKzIOsMLbJJ4cps0uQJS1DA4srdsVyDHh8l-Q6fDd0w/viewform?usp=header) and/or weigh in here

3 comments

speakingmoistly19d ago

I'll definitely be deterred from reading further once I get a smell of it being AI-generated (or too heavily AI-assisted) and would be less likely to read from whoever published it again. When it comes to translation, it depends more on the quality of the text (I always value a human translation higher than an AI / automated one, and low quality translation would turn me away).

The equation may also be a bit different if there's disclosure. If an author is being upfront about AI assistance that would materially affect the text, I might read further (provided that it's not just "AI wrote this and I barely proof-read it).

Ultimately, I'd be less likely to spend time and effort consuming something I have the feeling wasn't really the product of someone else's time and effort.

sha_rad19d ago

I personally appreciate 1. Disclaimer if it is AI written or assisted 2. Early mentioned of how AI was used for proofreading or images etc 3. Mention if AI wasn't used

I'm subconsciously leaning towards AI used unless explicitly declined

marysminefnuf19d ago

With disdain. I keep seeing cool articles and realize that they are made with ai by the ai images or just obvious writing tells and i immediately click away.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse