undefined | Better HN

0 pointsleptons2mo ago0 comments

>The user gets spammed with a million permissions popups a day and has no idea what they are actually accepting or what the risks are.

"A million" is quite the hyperbole. So let's just not do anything anymore because it might cause a permission popup? Or because some idiot might trust a scam website? That's your argument? Sorry, it's not a good argument.

>while the webusb spec is exposing you to potentially high risks of damage to hardware or data theft.

Please explain a realistic scenario where a website >that someone trusts< is going to "damage hardware or cause data theft".

I'll wait.

I don't care about someone's stupid grandfather that is going to find a way to get hacked one way or another - he's not a good reason to hold the rest of us back.

0 pointsleptons2mo ago0 comments

>The user gets spammed with a million permissions popups a day and has no idea what they are actually accepting or what the risks are.

>while the webusb spec is exposing you to potentially high risks of damage to hardware or data theft.

Please explain a realistic scenario where a website >that someone trusts< is going to "damage hardware or cause data theft".

I'll wait.

I don't care about someone's stupid grandfather that is going to find a way to get hacked one way or another - he's not a good reason to hold the rest of us back.

0 comments

4 comments · 1 top-level

Gigachad2mo ago· 3 in thread

That’s the source of the issue. Apple sells products that are safe for someone’s stupid grandfather. WebUSB is not safe for people who don’t understand the implications. Which is most people.

The rest can choose a different browser.

Rohansi2mo ago

> WebUSB is not safe for people who don’t understand the implications. Which is most people.

Why? What is the worst that could happen? The user needs to choose which device(s) to allow access to and browsers do not allow access to all of them.

leptonsOP2mo ago

>Apple sells products that are safe for someone’s stupid grandfather.

Then then they should be selling it in "grandfather mode". The rest of the non-stupid people that have iPhones (there are non-stupid people with iPhones, aren't there?) should be able to do what they want with their devices. But they can't because Apple puts profit over progress.

>The rest can choose a different browser.

Except on iOS you can't choose a different browser. Apple has blocked all other browsers on their mobile platform, so if you try to install Chrome, you're really just getting a Safari webview with a wrapper around it. It's just another example of abusive business tactics that the DOJ is suing Apple for.

Gigachad2mo ago

On iOS you can’t use usb anyway. Even an actual app can’t use usb outside of the wrapper APIs for file access and stuff. So it doesn’t really matter what safari supports here. And on macOS you can use any browser you want.

1 more reply

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse