Im somewhat in the middle. I see great things coming out of atmosphere and people who really mean well and do great work. But there are some of these significant gaps that are not addressed in what i think would be the appropriate manner. So far i don't assume too much ill will and instead consider they have many of these topics that matter to different people. If these are still unaddressed when the teams work on seemingly way less important topics is when we should really hear alarm bells. Not related but arc/ browser company using firebase without export and user access to their data was ok as long as it was an experiment in next gen browser UX, but when they started making haptic feedback for the slider to set your colour scheme, while not giving users a way to access their own spaces data was clear it was game over. ATproto is just an experiment no one should build serious things on until there are proper access controls and more importantly an independent European provider for plc.directory etc. and its provable to work without US company mercy.