The griping I read about Liquid Glass is from the unhip nerds on HN (like me). I don’t actually know what the industrial designers and graphic artists in their Soho lofts think. I asked an exec designer that I know IRL and got a shrug.
Other than that, I stand by my statement exactly. This is very bad.
Those other things add up and are definitely noticed by non-tech users that don't care that things like the alarm UI are massively regressed.