undefined | Better HN

0 pointsgpderetta2d ago0 comments

After dismissing it for a long time, I have come around to the philosophical zombie argument. I do not believe that LLMs are conscious, but I also no longer believe that consciousness is a prerequisite for intelligence. I think at this point it is hard to deny that LLMs do not possess some form of intelligence (although not necessarily human-like). I think P-zombies is a fitting description.

0 comments

zeroonetwothree1d ago

I don't think P-zombies can exist. There must be some perceptible difference between an intelligence w/ consciousness and one without. The only way there wouldn't be a difference is if we are mistaken about the consciousness (either both have it or neither do).

gpderettaOP1d ago

> There must be some perceptible difference between an intelligence w/ consciousness and one without

I think there are differences, and I think we can make good guesses, but I'm not sure we can reliably classify a P-zombie from a normal human from their behaviour with 100% accuracy..

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse

0 pointsgpderetta2d ago0 comments

0 comments

zeroonetwothree1d ago

gpderettaOP1d ago

> There must be some perceptible difference between an intelligence w/ consciousness and one without

I think there are differences, and I think we can make good guesses, but I'm not sure we can reliably classify a P-zombie from a normal human from their behaviour with 100% accuracy..

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse