Worthwhile to note that the author of this PR, Matteo Collina , is the lead maintainer of fastify and Chair of the Node.js Technical Steering Committee.
Title is misleading, there is an open discussion on the topic with someone raising valid points and a clear escalation method that involves a vote from another group.
I think this title is a little misleading? Rather it seems like they are just asking for clarification and discussing more clarity from the existing policy.