undefined | Better HN

0 pointsheavyset_go3mo ago0 comments

> (Also it’s not age verification really, it’s just a prompt that asks for your age to share as a system API for apps from above app store, no verification required)

It's not enough to adhere to the age signal:

> (3) (A) Except as provided in subparagraph (B), a developer shall treat a signal received pursuant to this title as the primary indicator of a user’s age range for purposes of determining the user’s age.

> (B) If a developer has internal clear and convincing information that a user’s age is different than the age indicated by a signal received pursuant to this title, the developer shall use that information as the primary indicator of the user’s age.

Developers are still burdened with additional liability if they have reason to believe users are underage, even if their age flag says otherwise.

The only way to mitigate this liability is to confirm your users are of age with facial and ID scans, that is why age verification systems are implemented that way: doing so minimizes liability for developers/providers and it's cheap.

0 comments

4 comments · 1 top-level

solid_fuel3mo ago· 3 in thread

> Developers are still burdened with additional liability if they have reason to believe users are underage, even if their age flag says otherwise.

This is true, but

> The only way to mitigate this liability is to confirm your users are of age with facial and ID scans,

This doesn’t follow. It says “if” the developer has clear reason, it doesn’t obligate the developer to collect additional information or build a profile.

I read this as - if you in the course of business come across evidence a user is under age, you can’t ignore it. For example - “you have to ban a user if they post comments saying they are actually underage”

heavyset_goOP3mo ago

That would have to be litigated in court, and the easiest and cheapest way to avoid litigation is to do what all platforms currently do: make sure the person using their system is who they say they are via face scans and ID checks.

As a developer, that is not the kind of liability I want to take on when I can just plug ID.me, or whatever, into my app and not worry if someone writes "im 12 lol" in a comment on my platform.

NetMageSCW3mo ago

Post where?

solid_fuel3mo ago

> a developer has internal clear and convincing information

Internally from the perspective of the developer implies: on the platform in question.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse