undefined | Better HN

0 pointscuu50813y ago0 comments

But in case of OEM Windows licence it is black and white, no?

What would be peoples motivation to buy it for existing computer?

* "It's sorta legal, it's at least some kind of a licence, right?" -- they're misinformed / tricked /fools

* "I want to pay something, but retail costs too much" -- if you pay without getting anything useful in return, you're donating. Why not donate to charity?

* "I want to get Windows Updates" -- cracked copies used to get updates, and they're often bundled with updates already applied

My point is, I don't understand buying half-valid licence. Licence is either valid or you have no licence.

0 comments

4 comments · 2 top-level

lmm13y ago· 2 in thread

>* "I want to pay something, but retail costs too much" -- if you pay without getting anything useful in return, you're donating. Why not donate to charity?

Because your sense of fair play says you've got something from MS so they, and not some random charity, deserve some of your money? Do you follow the same logic and donate to charity instead of tipping at restaurants?

Zak13y ago

It seems to me that many people treat software licences like physical goods in their minds.

The idea of buying a chef's knife from Victorinox for one price if it's to be used to chop vegetables and another if it's to be used to trim fat from steaks is absurd. You buy the knife at the lowest price it's offered and use it however you like.

Software licensing does include the ability to charge different prices for different usage scenarios, but violating those conditions doesn't strike most people as unethical while obtaining the software without paying seems similar to theft.

engtech13y ago

This is the same reason why the idea that you can't bequeath your iTunes purchases on death seems like lunacy to most people.

Purchased goods are purchased goods, and the idea that something is licensed with restrictions seems ridiculous to most people unless it's something upfront like a subscription that you are paying monthly fees to access.

1 more reply

slackito13y ago

I think a valid, although not legal, motivation for that could be "I just want something Microsoft will activate because I want a clean (i.e.: without applying a random crack from the Internet which could install malware) Windows install, at the minimum possible cost".

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse