undefined | Better HN

0 pointsKarunamon13y ago0 comments

>it's very demoralizing to have non-constructive, abusive comments like the above ("crap interface" )?

I'm sorry, compared to standard GNOME (v2, v3 can join Unity on the junkpile IMAO) or KDE, Unity is crap, and I am hardly alone in that opinion.

Perhaps certain open source developers just suck at taking any kind of criticism? That's sure what these moves feel like.

I would bet large sums of money we're going to see something distasteful come of this, along the lines of further intrusive desktop advertising ala Amazon Lens.

Maybe if you would start listening to the community more when there's a large outcry (amazon lens, unity, gnome 3, etc etc etc) there would be fewer people who feel they are "entitled" to a desktop experience that doesn't suck!

0 comments

incision13y ago

>I'm sorry, compared to standard GNOME or KDE, Unity is crap, and I am hardly alone in that opinion.

Missing the point completely.

The parent was pretty clear about "non-constructive, abusive" being the issue, not the argument for or against Unity you're trying to frame.

spindritf13y ago

I like both Unity and integrated search allowing me to easily access whatever I'm looking for whether it's locally or on Google Docs/Drive. It's possible that I'm an outlier but I don't think that's the case.

I don't think people who routinely use Gmail, Flickr, Facebook, Dropbox, or virtually any other online service care deeply about a few searches being anonymously forwarded to Amazon.

donniezazen13y ago

Can you explain in great details questioning the design choices made by Unity and how it is crap. I like both Unity and Gnome 3.

KarunamonOP13y ago

http://www.dedoimedo.com/computers/unity.html

http://www.dedoimedo.com/computers/gnome-3.html

Same guy, takes the words out of my mouth in both cases.

Worth mentioning is that they have, admittedly, made a great deal of progress. Unity isn't the buggy mess that it was back a couple of major releases ago, which renders moot a good deal of the author's complaints.

I could still do without the mandatory 3d acceleration (which wouldn't be so bad if they would leave Unity 2D alone but nope, they're killing that off.....) and the full screen , space wasting interface. I am on a desktop, not a netbook. Optimize accordingly, please.

Unity is a fine interface for smaller screens and mobile devices. Not so much for the desktop.

wtetzner13y ago

It seems weird to me that power users need so much GUI support. I find Gnome 3 very convenient. If I need to launch a program, I press the super key, start typing the name, and press enter. It's like using IDO mode in Emacs.

As far as I'm concerned, most of the stuff they removed was just noise.

There are a couple things I dislike about Gnome 3 though. There doesn't seem to be an obvious way to set the Date/Time format. Also, it's annoying that you have to install the Gnome Tweak Tool to set things like focus follows mouse, instead of it just being part of the Gnome settings.

But these are pretty minor things.

donniezazen13y ago

Thanks, one of the biggest problems with Gnome 3 is that there is not even one distribution that actively promotes Gnome 3, get rid of kinks, themes it, and make it look like modern DE/OS. Fedora is a lot of work, Arch Linux believes in KISS. On the other hand Ubuntu does everything for you.

jfoutz13y ago

Oh, right the guy who said: "Unity 3D behaves spectacularly on all tested hardware, including old and new graphics cards. The performance is quite good, the responsiveness is great, and you even get reduced power consumption."

1 more reply

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse

0 pointsKarunamon13y ago0 comments

>it's very demoralizing to have non-constructive, abusive comments like the above ("crap interface" )?

I'm sorry, compared to standard GNOME (v2, v3 can join Unity on the junkpile IMAO) or KDE, Unity is crap, and I am hardly alone in that opinion.

Perhaps certain open source developers just suck at taking any kind of criticism? That's sure what these moves feel like.

I would bet large sums of money we're going to see something distasteful come of this, along the lines of further intrusive desktop advertising ala Amazon Lens.

0 comments

incision13y ago

>I'm sorry, compared to standard GNOME or KDE, Unity is crap, and I am hardly alone in that opinion.

Missing the point completely.

The parent was pretty clear about "non-constructive, abusive" being the issue, not the argument for or against Unity you're trying to frame.

spindritf13y ago

I don't think people who routinely use Gmail, Flickr, Facebook, Dropbox, or virtually any other online service care deeply about a few searches being anonymously forwarded to Amazon.

donniezazen13y ago

Can you explain in great details questioning the design choices made by Unity and how it is crap. I like both Unity and Gnome 3.

KarunamonOP13y ago

http://www.dedoimedo.com/computers/unity.html

http://www.dedoimedo.com/computers/gnome-3.html

Same guy, takes the words out of my mouth in both cases.

Unity is a fine interface for smaller screens and mobile devices. Not so much for the desktop.

wtetzner13y ago

As far as I'm concerned, most of the stuff they removed was just noise.

But these are pretty minor things.

donniezazen13y ago

jfoutz13y ago

1 more reply

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse