undefined | Better HN

0 pointsako2mo ago0 comments

> I agree, but I think I'm less optimistic than you that Claude will be able to catch its own mistakes in the future. On the other hand, I can definitely see how a ~more intelligent model might be able to catch mistakes on a larger and larger scale.

Claude already does this. Yesterday i asked it why some functionality was slow, it did some research, and then came back with all the right performance numbers, how often certain code was called, and opportunities to cache results to speed up execution. It refactored the code, ran performance tests, and reported the performance improvements.

0 comments

ekidd2mo ago

I have been reading through this thread, and my first reaction to many of the comments was "Skill issue."

Yes, it can build things that have never existed before. Yes, it can review its own code. Yes, it can do X, Y and Z.

Does it do all these things spontaneously with no structure? No, it doesn't. Are there tricks to getting it do some of these things? Yup. If you want code review, start by writing a code review "skill". Have that skill ask Opus to fork off several subagents to review different aspects, and then synthesize the reports, with issues broken down by Critical, Major and Minor. Have the skill describe all the things you want from a review.

There are, as the OP pointed out, a lot of reasons why you can't run it with no human at all. But with an experienced human nudging it? It can do a lot.

akoOP2mo ago

It's basically not very different from working with an average development team as a product owner/manager: you need to feed it specific requirements or it will hallucinate some requirements, bugs are expected, even with unit test and testers on the team. And yes, as a product owner you also make mistakes, never have all the requirements up front, but the nice thing working with a GenAI coder is that you can iterate over these requirement gaps, hallucinated requirements and bugs in minutes, not in days.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse