undefined | Better HN

0 pointsEridrus4mo ago0 comments

Google is actually kind of infamous for not using much in the way of OSS software.

The list of things I can think of is:

* Linux

* LLVM

* Webkit/Chrome (which they have done the majority of contributions to for a long time)

* Java & a little bit of Python

0 comments

fooker4mo ago

There's a whole lot more, check `third_party/` if you work at Google.

(disclaimer, used to work at google a long time ago)

EridrusOP4mo ago

There were directories there for sure, but I honestly never saw anything get used from there (except I think TensorFlow was in there?).

My personal experience was I never used any OSS code (that wasn't Google Open Sourcing its own code) except Linux & LLVM.

It definitely didn't feel meaningful to the company besides the ones I called out.

galkk4mo ago

A lot of it also comes from acquired projects/companies, that are brought to google3, with plans to deprecate and get rid of eventually

dust424mo ago

So if you subtract linux and LLVM and Webkit and Java, what is left of Google? Absolutely nothing. Well, a mostly empty, dysfunctional mono repo lacking the main dependencies.

EridrusOP4mo ago

I don't think the company would be very different if these projects had never existed and everyone had to pay for proprietary tools.

The people meaningfully benefiting from open source are the people and companies on the margin, not the biggest tech companies in the world.

tehlike4mo ago

Come on.

doublerabbit4mo ago

Oh yeah, manipulating users and monetary siphoning data with their advertising schemes.

HeyMeco4mo ago

For Linux / ChromeOS: GPU drivers benefit heavily: - Freedreno for Qualcomm - Panthor for Arm Mali

Lots of Linux contributions for Rust drivers

atonse4mo ago

V8 (covered in Chrome), Angular, Dart, Golang, Kubernetes, Android (remember Android???)

DrBenCarson4mo ago

Didn’t they open source Kubernetes (aka probably the biggest OSS project since Linux itself)

jeffbee4mo ago

Biggest in what sense? Certainly not in terms of the size of the code base. It is an order of magnitude smaller than Chromium.

manmal4mo ago

Oh, only Linux? /s

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse

0 comments

fooker4mo ago

There's a whole lot more, check `third_party/` if you work at Google.

(disclaimer, used to work at google a long time ago)

EridrusOP4mo ago

There were directories there for sure, but I honestly never saw anything get used from there (except I think TensorFlow was in there?).

My personal experience was I never used any OSS code (that wasn't Google Open Sourcing its own code) except Linux & LLVM.

It definitely didn't feel meaningful to the company besides the ones I called out.

galkk4mo ago

A lot of it also comes from acquired projects/companies, that are brought to google3, with plans to deprecate and get rid of eventually

dust424mo ago

So if you subtract linux and LLVM and Webkit and Java, what is left of Google? Absolutely nothing. Well, a mostly empty, dysfunctional mono repo lacking the main dependencies.

EridrusOP4mo ago

I don't think the company would be very different if these projects had never existed and everyone had to pay for proprietary tools.

The people meaningfully benefiting from open source are the people and companies on the margin, not the biggest tech companies in the world.

tehlike4mo ago

Come on.

doublerabbit4mo ago

Oh yeah, manipulating users and monetary siphoning data with their advertising schemes.

HeyMeco4mo ago

For Linux / ChromeOS: GPU drivers benefit heavily: - Freedreno for Qualcomm - Panthor for Arm Mali

Lots of Linux contributions for Rust drivers

atonse4mo ago

V8 (covered in Chrome), Angular, Dart, Golang, Kubernetes, Android (remember Android???)

DrBenCarson4mo ago

Didn’t they open source Kubernetes (aka probably the biggest OSS project since Linux itself)

jeffbee4mo ago

Biggest in what sense? Certainly not in terms of the size of the code base. It is an order of magnitude smaller than Chromium.

manmal4mo ago

Oh, only Linux? /s

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse