undefined | Better HN

0 pointsxp842mo ago0 comments

As a fellow parent, I cannot recommend Apple Arcade enough. My son is only allowed to play games that come from AA. These games aren't allowed to have any ads or in-app purchase. In return, you pay seven measly bucks a month (though I have it included as part of a package since we use iCloud and Apple Music and Apple TV+ anyway).

The games in AA are either made for Apple Arcade (some great indie type games) or, very commonly, they are basically 'de-fanged' ones from the regular App Store, with all the IAPs and ads ripped out. Where there is an in-game currency that normally is scarce without paying, they'll either just give you a bunch of it to start with, or you will earn it naturally while playing.

I agree with you that the number of ads and purchase-pushing mechanics in all regular App Store/Play Store games is insane. It's all because a few whales who do buy these purchases are what pays for the whole thing.

0 comments

BeetleB2mo ago

Know of an equivalent for Android?

I'm leaning towards letting the kid play games only on an XBox and never on the phone. Even if I get rid of the ads, I don't want the games to be accessible wherever they are. Whereas with a TV, they need to situate themselves in a dedicated place to play games.

xp84OP2mo ago

I haven't used it much, because I was dragged kicking and screaming back to iOS by family inertia (photo library and iMessage), but there is this which bills itself as the same idea:

https://play.google.com/store/pass/getstarted

xp84OP2mo ago

> only on an XBox and never on the phone. ... I don't want the games to be accessible wherever they are.

I couldn't agree more that a carry-anywhere gaming (or worse, social-media) device is too corrosive to childhood.[1] My eldest is only 7, so unsurprisingly he doesn't have a phone, and uses an iPad. The size of it has a nice side-effect that it's impractical to carry around, so it's only used at home and in the car.

When he's older, I plan to give him a phone that can only text and call.

[1] Sure, some of us had things like Game Boy, but consider how long those batteries even lasted, how bulky and limited the devices were, how expensive games were, how there were zero ads... It's really far from the same thing. I'd be fine with him having a thing like a Game Boy.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse

0 pointsxp842mo ago0 comments

0 comments

BeetleB2mo ago

Know of an equivalent for Android?

xp84OP2mo ago

I haven't used it much, because I was dragged kicking and screaming back to iOS by family inertia (photo library and iMessage), but there is this which bills itself as the same idea:

https://play.google.com/store/pass/getstarted

xp84OP2mo ago

> only on an XBox and never on the phone. ... I don't want the games to be accessible wherever they are.

When he's older, I plan to give him a phone that can only text and call.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse