undefined | Better HN

0 pointsstavros4mo ago0 comments

And you find yourself less productive?

0 comments

No but I don't use it to generate code usually.

I gave agents a solid go and I didn't feel more productive, just became more stupid.

A year or so ago I was seriously thinking of making a series of videos showing how coding agents were just plain bad at producing code. This was based on my experience trying to get them to do very simple things (e.g. a five-pointed star, or text flowing around the edge of circle, in HTML/CSS). They still tend to fail at things like this, but I've come to realize that there are whole classes of adjacent problems they're good at, and I'm starting to leverage their strengths rather than get hung up on their weaknesses.

Perhaps you're not playing to their strengths, or just haven't cracked the code for how to prompt them effectively? Prompt engineering is an art, and slight changes to prompts can make a big difference in the resulting code.

anhner4mo ago

and what are those strengths, if you don't mind me asking?

kmoser4mo ago

  - Providing boilerplate/template code for common use cases
  - Explaining what code is doing and how it works
  - Refactoring/updating code when given specific requirements
  - Providing alternative ways of doing things that you might not have thought of yourself

YMMV; every project is different so you might not have occasion to use all of these at the same time.

1 more reply

llmslave24mo ago

Perhaps it is a skill issue. But I don't really see the point of trying when it seems like the gains are marginal. If agent workflows really do start offering 2x+ level improvements then perhaps I'll switch over, in the meantime I won't have to suffer mental degradation from constant LLM usage.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse

0 comments

llmslave24mo ago

No but I don't use it to generate code usually.

I gave agents a solid go and I didn't feel more productive, just became more stupid.

kmoser4mo ago

anhner4mo ago

and what are those strengths, if you don't mind me asking?

kmoser4mo ago

  - Providing boilerplate/template code for common use cases
  - Explaining what code is doing and how it works
  - Refactoring/updating code when given specific requirements
  - Providing alternative ways of doing things that you might not have thought of yourself

YMMV; every project is different so you might not have occasion to use all of these at the same time.

1 more reply

llmslave24mo ago

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse