If I see a human copying me, I know for a fact at least one person was impacted by what I do. Even if that person never acknowledges me publicly, or forgets I even exist, I know for a fact that what I did meant something.

Scrapers gobble everything up. Good, bad, memorable, non-memorable. Doesn't matter. I don't know, maybe one day I'll make a small piece of code that changes how an AI behaves (profoundly, by being in the training data, not superficially when used in the prompt). However, that hasn't happened yet. I also think it's unlikely to happen.

I know this isn't what you were going for, but it's good enough for this discussion to estabilish a critical difference. I don't even have to touch consciousness or anything like that to argue within those lines.