undefined | Better HN

0 pointsmagicalist7mo ago0 comments

> I will go meta into what you posted here: That people are classifying themselves as "AI skeptics"

The comment you're replying to is calling other people AI skeptics.

Your advice has some fine parts to it (and simonw's comment is innocuous in its use of the term), but if we're really going meta, you seem to be engaging in the tribal conflict you're decrying by lecturing an imaginary person rather than the actual context of what you're responding to.

0 comments

2 comments · 1 top-level

pweezy7mo ago· 1 in thread

To me, "Tip for AI skeptics" reads as shorthand for "Tip for those of you who classify as AI skeptics".

That is why the meta commentary about identity politics made complete sense to me. It's simply observing that this discussion (like so many others) tends to go this way, and suggests a better alternative - without a straw man.

tbrownaw7mo ago

I read it more as a claim that people who advocate against AI are picking arguments as a means to an end rather than because they actually believe or care about what they're saying.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse