undefined | Better HN

0 pointsTade04mo ago0 comments

> and their internal state is no longer static and deterministic (and they become Turing complete!).

But it's not the LLM that makes modifications in those databases - it just retrieves data which is already there.

> Why would you travelling through time suddenly erases all other minds in reality?

I'm not following you here.

> they are active minds while they are processing a prompt.

Problem is that this process doesn't affect the LLM in the slightest. It just regurgitates what it's been taught. An active mind is makes itself. It's curious, it gets bored, it's learning constantly. LLMs do none of that.

You couldn't get a real mind to answer the same question hundreds of times without it being changed by that experience.

0 comments

naasking4mo ago

> But it's not the LLM that makes modifications in those databases - it just retrieves data which is already there.

So what?

> I'm not following you here.

If you're time travelling, you're resetting the state of the world to some previous well-defined, static state. An LLM also starts from some well-defined static state. You claim this static configuration means there's no mind, so this entails that the ability to time travel means that every person who is not time travelling has no mind.

> Problem is that this process doesn't affect the LLM in the slightest. It just regurgitates what it's been taught. An active mind is makes itself.

People who are incapable forming new memories thus don't have minds?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anterograde_amnesia

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse