undefined | Better HN

0 pointsarthurcolle5mo ago0 comments

I learned a few things from my father along the way. I can share my notes if you'd like

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ronald_Coll%C3%A9?wprov=sfti1

0 comments

I'm sure your father is a very accomplished gentleman. But I was asking why your armchair analysis is better than the experts who actually know what happened here?

arthurcolleOP5mo ago

I maintain the complete archive of every publication my father did from 1969 to 2019 and continue to update the archive based on new publications. I use the data to train Nuclear Radiochemistry AI Agents and while I do not have my father's credentials, I actively use this dataset to learn about his field, and from my limited knowledge here I felt the need to comment. After all, what is skepticism if we can't share and teach each other what we know, right?

https://github.com/arthurcolle/Ronald-Colle-Papers

I love how punchy you are! And the astronomy photos. Take care :)

C6JEsQeQa5fCjE5mo ago

> I use the data to train Nuclear Radiochemistry AI Agents and [...]

As someone who is not involved in this ongoing discussion, I have to just say that invoking LLM agents when asked for credentials is not going to go in your favor.

1 more reply

not_kurt_godel5mo ago

So you don't have the necessary credentials, and you still wouldn't be qualified to comment even if you did have them unless you had access to the internal data. But no worries, I'm sure you'd be OK getting surgery from a surgeon's son who never went to medical school nor read your chart.

2 more replies

aunty_helen5mo ago

> Collé and his collaborators have maintained, expanded and improved radioactivity measurement standards...

Story checks out. I think this would pass.

kbar135mo ago

LMFAOOOOOO insufferable

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse