undefined | Better HN

0 pointsnotapenny6mo ago0 comments

For sure it isn't the perfect solution for everything, and I say that as someone who spends most of their time in either React or Angular now. For application-like development or just sites with tons of interaction it's become as standard as reaching for Spring or PSQL though.

I can't speak to the complexity you've encountered, but for me it's pretty much zero. A button component is just a function. React-Router is good enough and code splitting is pretty much just changing how to import something. Component state is dead-easy to write by just adding a useState hook. Bundlers pretty much handle everything these days so not to much concern about size.

Your view on front-end developers having been mediocre in the past isn't far off though, at least in my experience. I noticed a big difference between the people who wanted to build nice looking pages and the ones that wanted to build applications myself. Even today it amazes me how many people have never unit tested their code, have no idea about layering an application and have poor JS/TS fundamentals. It's gotten a lot better though.

Ultimately it isn't perfect for everything, but for a lot of people it's an easy choice. And for me personally, the tons of other JS frameworks do very little in that area that I'd pick them. I'd rather spend my time working on the product. Lol, maybe its just the default because its the default at this point.

0 comments

spartanatreyu6mo ago

> I can't speak to the complexity you've encountered, but for me it's pretty much zero. A button component is just a function. React-Router is good enough and code splitting is pretty much just changing how to import something. Component state is dead-easy to write by just adding a useState hook. Bundlers pretty much handle everything these days so not to much concern about size.

For me, everything depends on the site and the host.

For 80% of websites, a button is <button>, a router is just URLs that point to files, a state is just a json object in localStorage.

For 15% of websites, a button is <button>, a router is a single file that imports an auth provider and a storage provider which are chosen based on the host.

For the remaining 5% of websites which are actually true applications, I'd reach for a RoR inspired framework (so Laravel for PHP host, Adonis for js host, etc...).

No react needed.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse