undefined | Better HN

0 pointstraceroute666mo ago0 comments

> things have gone too far in children being able to access

Look, the reality is that kids will be kids ...

Remember the pre-internet days when the porn mags were on the top-shelf at the newsagent ?

I'm sure many of that generation will tell you stories of copies of Playboy being passed around in the school playground.

Or back in the VHS or DVD days .... someone in the playground would be passing around some porn.

Or, a UK-centric example would be the famous Page 3 of The Sun newspaper.... "giggle giggle...boobies...giggle"

Moving swiftly forward to the modern day. You can legislate about it all you like, but kids know their way around tech and will soon discover what you can do with a VPN or any of the other many workarounds.

I think the reality is more that the government is trying to legislate for things that could be resolved by good old-fashioned parenting and teaching.

Educating your child properly is better than doing the helicopter-parenting routine and trying to smother little Billy in cotton wool.

0 comments

sunrabbit6mo ago

Previously, it was controlled by kingship Now, we suppress freedom under the pretext of safety.

If you have read "1984", the story is fast.

I'm a korean, And a fake news censorship law has been drafted here. When We asked what the standard of fake was, the answer came back that "it was not important".

It's actually the case. Because they already have standards.

physicsguy6mo ago

You say that but I’m sat at the cricket match today listening to another Dad talking about their 11 year old kid turning on their phone this week and watching a video they’ve been sent by another chile of Charlie Kirk being shot by another child. That’s not going looking for it right?

traceroute66OP6mo ago

The trouble is where are you going to stop ?

Are you going to not allow the kid access to mainstream radio or TV incase they watch/listen to the news where you have eye-witnesses being interviewed, often live with minimal/no editing ?

Or not allow the kid to visit mainstream media news websites, because most mainstream media outlets copied the same social media clip you referred to and just edited out the exact moment. But the kid can still use their imagination for that half-second moment.

Are you not going to take them on public transport incase some adults start chatting about it in detail ?

Don't get me wrong, I see your perspective.

But the point is there are so many moving parts to today's fast moving world that you can't put them all back in the box, wave a magic wand and revert to the pre-internet days where there were only four TV channels showing highly scripted content.

Yes modern parenting is tough. But thinking everything can be solved just by throwing more and more broadly (and badly) worded highly-intrusive kitchen-sink legislation at it is not the answer either.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse