undefined | Better HN

0 pointsmdhb10mo ago0 comments

But this is exactly what I mean. I’m not shooting anyone over a fucking robbery for gods sake.. it’s such an incredibly disproportionate response to the situation. Likewise, there’s almost no situation where he was ever going to shoot you. Just hand over your shit and move on, everyone can go home to their families.

The only scenario where things start to get ACTUALLY dangerous is you pulling out a weapon and suddenly you’ve gone from a 5/10 situation to a 10/10 situation where everyone is liable to panic and do something stupid. You’re about to go from a bad day to maybe your last day here and for what? There is just no point in that story where adding another weapon to the picture improved things at all.

On a side note, I think there is a LOT to be said for having a strong sense of situation awareness and how to do risk management on the street. I spent a good amount of time years ago living in Nairobi and I was one of the few people in my circle of friends who didn’t have a gun in their face at any point. I’m not trying to say I’m somehow special, I think that can happen to anyone but I wish people didn’t have their entire personal security model centered around having a weapon because it’s actually a really shit plan in real life.

Edit: I don’t know if you’re familiar with Robert Young Pelton but he is a war correspondent wrote a book called the worlds most dangerous places which is part adventure travel guide and part how to stay safe in actually honest to god dangerous places and situations. He just started a podcast based on that book and I think you might get something out of this: https://youtu.be/3dhh5_oJsqQ?feature=shared

0 comments

3 comments · 1 top-level

mothballed10mo ago· 2 in thread

If someone is intentionally pulling a gun on you, you should expect they intend to kill you with it, and respond appropriately. And if having a chambered weapon is as dangerous as you say, then you should also maybe expect, they might accidently set the gun off at any time. That's a no from me dog. I'm not just going to pray they only just want my shit, and don't intend to use it to rape my wife, or my child, or even me, or just to kill me for the lolz.

And yeah I've been in the third world, including Syria. I think the penalty for me having one in Syria was probably the death penalty (LOL!), I didn't give a shit. Some people did shoot at me, I survived.

mdhbOP10mo ago

But this is again what I am saying. Of course you can get yourself into such a state where you immediately go to the worst possible case scenario and get yourself so worked up where the only logical conclusion is that you need a weapon with one in the chamber at all time… just in case.

But that is just being scared and has nothing to do with actually assessing and managing risk.

mothballed10mo ago

A modern striker fired pistol that is designed properly (like glock gen 3+) is not going to go off unless you pull the trigger. I don't understand why you wouldn't carry it chambered, if you are going to carry. You shouldn't be pulling it out of the holster unless you are about to shoot someone with it, at which point, why just stand around racking it and hoping it doesn't jam?

1 more reply

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse