undefined | Better HN

0 pointschvid8mo ago0 comments

Macs today are not designed to be easily repairably but instead to be lighter and otherwise better integrated - I believe that is consequence of consumer preferences and not shady business practices.

As for the services - it is a bit off topic as I believe Apple makes a profit on their macs alone ignoring their services business. But in general I have less of a problem with a subscription / fee-driven services business compared to an advertisement-based one. And as for the fee / alternative payment controversy (epic vs apple etc.) this is something that is relevant if you are a big brand that can actually market on your own / build an alternative shop infrastructure. For small time developers the marketing and payment infrastructure the apple app store offers is a bargain.

0 comments

omnimus8mo ago

Macbooks are one of the heaviest laptops you can buy. I think they are doing it for the premium feel - it is extremely sturdy. I recently got some random lenovo YOGA for linux to go along side my macbook and it weighs less, is as thin and even has dedicated gpu - while having 2 user replaceable M.2 slots. It is also very sturdy but not as sturdy Macbooks.

What i am saying is that Apple could for sure fit replaceable drives without any change hit to size or weight. But their Mac strategy is price based on disk size and make repairs expensive so you buy new machine. I don't complain it is the reason why cheapest Macbook Air is the best laptop deal.

But let's stop this marketing story that it's their engineering genius not their market strategy.

weighterjsk8mo ago

>Macbooks are one of the heaviest laptops you can buy.

I don't think this is even close to true. My last laptop from 2020 weighed at ~2.6kg and it's 2025 counterpart is still at 2.1kg, while my work m1 mac is at 1.3kg

>. I think they are doing it for the premium feel - it is extremely sturdy

It's not merely a feel; I've succesfully thrown it to the pavement more than once from ~1.5 meters and it's continued working well, whereas none of my previous laptops have gotten away scot free before from even one drop

Apple does practice very hard repairability which I agree should be made much more accessible.

aurareturn8mo ago

  Macbooks are one of the heaviest laptops you can buy. I think they are doing it for the premium feel - it is extremely sturdy.

Yes, because of the metal enclosure while nearly all Windows laptop makers use plastic. Macs are usually the thinnest laptops in their class though.

queenkjuul8mo ago

My Asus is all metal, thinner, and lighter than my same-screen-size MacBook

It's also not as robust. But it's definitely thinner and lighter.

chvidOP8mo ago

I am pretty sure it is a consequence of consumer preference. I can see it from my own behaviour - I am a power user of all things computing and it has been decades since I upgraded a harddisk.

prewett8mo ago

Regarding storage, part of the advantage of their soldered storage is higher access speeds. Combined with the fact that, as you note, people rarely need to upgrade their storage, might as well use the faster storage. This is probably particularly a benefit for the 8 GB machines, which I assume use swap regularly.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse