undefined | Better HN

story

0 pointsqcnguy9mo ago0 comments

The UK didn't want unlimited immigration from the EU, and the EU refused to even consider the possibility of an exception, so the UK left.

It's not complicated, it's old history, and the fact that people are still describing this as "brits dumb hurhur" is racist and abusive. The idea that it could have got an exception, by the way, is yet more federalist lying. Cameron did a tour around Europe directly visiting member states, begging them to grant such an exception, and they refused. He returned with his "deal", presented it to the country and never mentioned it again during his campaign because it was an insult to the concerns of the voters.

0 comments

gambiting9mo ago

>>The UK didn't want unlimited immigration from the EU,

It was never unlimited and it's yet another lie peddled by Farage and the Brexit campaign.

UK could have always at the very least enforced the basic of the EU free movement principles in terms of limitations - namely that anyone without a job or means to provide for themselves for over 3 months can be kicked out. That would have solved most of the discontent around the issue. Similarily, UK not being in the schoengen zone could have interviewed everyone arriving from the EU - why are they coming here, do they have funds, do they have a job and turn around people it suspected are coming for benefits etc. It chose not to do that. It was entirely legal at the time and it could have been done. But instead politicians lied about UK being "forced" to accept unlimited immigration, which was never true.

It's not even about exceptions - it could have just used the existing laws that were there.

>>Cameron did a tour around Europe directly visiting member states, begging them to grant such an exception

You and I have a very different understanding of how that visit worked.

>> it was an insult to the concerns of the voters.

It's just really funny to me how after Brexit yes, migration from EU has gone down but it was replaced entirely by migration from former British Empire instead. So I'm not sure if the "concerns of voters" was really respected here either way.

qcnguyOP9mo ago

The concerns of voters were absolutely not respected, you are completely right about that. The political class is completely bought into mass migration being a moral good, which is why getting it under control requires a complete replacement of that political class.

There were lots of things the UK could have done in theory which wouldn't have had any impact in reality. You can interview people and ask, do you have funds? Do you have a job? They say yes and go in, that's the end of it. There isn't a way under EU law to just say no there are too many people already, you can't come.

gambiting9mo ago

>>You can interview people and ask, do you have funds? Do you have a job? They say yes and go in, that's the end of it.

How do you think this works now then? Or how it worked with non-EU people before Brexit? You asked them and they had to provide proof. If they couldn't they were turned around. It's not rocket science.

>>There isn't a way under EU law to just say no there are too many people already, you can't come.

And again, the existing legal ways of removing EU immigrants would have helped with that, but it was easier to take the entire country of the EU than just use them.

>>The political class is completely bought into mass migration being a moral good

Which political class? Tories which have been in power for forever? the same Tories who ran the "hostile environment" company against immigrants? Or Labour, which is now making it much harder and more expensive to both get in and stay in this country legally?

phatfish9mo ago

The best part of Brexit is that the EU protected us from the worst of destitute economic migrants. The southern EU countries were dealing with most of them, we just had to give them some cash to help. France also was more willing to deal with them for us.

We got internal migration from other EU countries (eastern Europe, Spain, Italy mostly) with much higher living standards. EU migrants are much more likely to return to their home countries after a period saving some cash and practising English.

But even that was too much for the poor old Brits.

Now we have people from African war zones and Indian villages and they are NEVER going back voluntarily. France isn't bothered any more because we behaved like spoiled children during Brexit, they wave them off on the Normandy beaches.

After burning bridges with Europe the only solution for the illegals is to go full Nazi and sink their boats in the channel like Farage wants to. Even if he somehow became PM I don't see that happening.

Anyway, legal migration is by far the biggest source, and those are mostly Indian villagers that are happy to have an inside toilet and not be fried by 40c+ heat most of the year. They are here forever too. BTW, a lot of Indians in the UK at the time were really happy about Brexit, i wonder why...

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse

0 comments

gambiting9mo ago

>>The UK didn't want unlimited immigration from the EU,

It was never unlimited and it's yet another lie peddled by Farage and the Brexit campaign.

It's not even about exceptions - it could have just used the existing laws that were there.

>>Cameron did a tour around Europe directly visiting member states, begging them to grant such an exception

You and I have a very different understanding of how that visit worked.

>> it was an insult to the concerns of the voters.

qcnguyOP9mo ago

gambiting9mo ago

>>You can interview people and ask, do you have funds? Do you have a job? They say yes and go in, that's the end of it.

>>There isn't a way under EU law to just say no there are too many people already, you can't come.

And again, the existing legal ways of removing EU immigrants would have helped with that, but it was easier to take the entire country of the EU than just use them.

>>The political class is completely bought into mass migration being a moral good

phatfish9mo ago

But even that was too much for the poor old Brits.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse