undefined | Better HN

0 pointsflir7mo ago0 comments

> For example, if you are an ELO 1000 chess player would you yourself be able to tell if Magnus Carlson or another grandmaster were better by playing them individually?

Yes, because I'd get them to play each other?

0 comments

cylemons7mo ago

He specifically said play them individually.

flirOP7mo ago

I know. "You can't assess which chatbot's more intelligent if I exclude the most obvious method of assessment" isn't a fair test.

cylemons7mo ago

I guess the analogy flawed, because it is not a competition where we can pit the chatbots against each other directly

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse

0 pointsflir7mo ago0 comments

> For example, if you are an ELO 1000 chess player would you yourself be able to tell if Magnus Carlson or another grandmaster were better by playing them individually?

Yes, because I'd get them to play each other?

0 comments

cylemons7mo ago

He specifically said play them individually.

flirOP7mo ago

I know. "You can't assess which chatbot's more intelligent if I exclude the most obvious method of assessment" isn't a fair test.

cylemons7mo ago

I guess the analogy flawed, because it is not a competition where we can pit the chatbots against each other directly

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse