undefined | Better HN

0 points4gotunameagain8mo ago0 comments

Yeah. And?

One case is an assertion of sovereignty (whether we agree or not), the other case is apartheid.

0 comments

tome8mo ago

I'm not sure what you mean. I'm saying that the reason that Arabs with Israeli passports are not allowed to enter certain areas of the West Bank is because no one with an Israeli passport is allowed to enter those areas.

4gotunameagainOP8mo ago

What I pointed out is that there are areas within Israel where Arabs with an Israeli passport cannot enter.

Areas outside of Israeli control where Israelis are not allowed to go is irrelevant when discussing about whether Israel is an apartheid state or not.

tome8mo ago

> What I pointed out is that there are areas within Israel where Arabs with an Israeli passport cannot enter.

Actually you said

> in the occupied areas Arabs WITH Israeli passports are not allowed to visit certain areas

But in any case, since you also said "multiple sources online" perhaps you can link one so we're talking about something concrete and not just vague insinuations.

1 more reply

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse

0 comments

tome8mo ago

4gotunameagainOP8mo ago

What I pointed out is that there are areas within Israel where Arabs with an Israeli passport cannot enter.

Areas outside of Israeli control where Israelis are not allowed to go is irrelevant when discussing about whether Israel is an apartheid state or not.

tome8mo ago

> What I pointed out is that there are areas within Israel where Arabs with an Israeli passport cannot enter.

Actually you said

> in the occupied areas Arabs WITH Israeli passports are not allowed to visit certain areas

But in any case, since you also said "multiple sources online" perhaps you can link one so we're talking about something concrete and not just vague insinuations.

1 more reply

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse