undefined | Better HN

0 pointsgowld1y ago0 comments

Do you have any evidence that these supposed assumptions exist?

No one donates $100K to the opera because they enjoy attending opera $1M worth. It's absurd to accuse any opera organization of assuming that.

Someone buys a ticket to the opera for $100 because they enjoy attending opera >$100 worth. They donate $100K because they want other people to enjoy opera, or for personal advertising purposes, not charitable social purposes.

0 comments

3 comments · 1 top-level

jwarden1y ago· 2 in thread

> Do you have any evidence that these supposed assumptions exist?

By existing, so you mean “hold in reality?”

The point of the article is that the assumption that underly QF do not hold in reality.

andrewflnr1y ago

I believe they were asking for evidence that (significant numbers of) people hold those assumptions.

TJSomething1y ago

I don't think the author was claiming that significant number of people hold those assumptions. I thought the assumption was that the most people implementing QF believe that QF is optimal for their use case. However, the author's observed use cases tend to not match the preconditions for QF's optimality.

1 more reply

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse