undefined | Better HN

0 pointskeerthiko1y ago0 comments

i got $100 of credit at the start of the year, and have been using +1$ each month, starting at $2 in january using aider at the time. just switched to claude code this week, since it follows a similar UX. agentic CLI code assist really has been growing in usefulness for me as i get faster at reviewing its output.

i use it for very targeted operations where it saves me several roundtrips to code examples and documentation and stack overflow, not spamming it for every task i need to do, i spend about $1/day of focused feature development, and it feels like it saves me about 50% as many hours as i spend coding while using it.

0 comments

stavros1y ago

What do you prefer, between Aider and CC? I use Aider for when I want to vibe code (I just give the LLM a high-level description and then don't check the output, because it's so long), and Cursor when I want to AI code (I tell the AI to do low-level stuff and check every one of the five lines it gives me).

AI coding saves me a lot of time writing high-quality code, as it takes care of the boilerplate and documentation/API lookups, while I still review every line, and vibe coding lets me quickly do small stuff I couldn't do before (e.g. write a whole app in React Native), but gets really brittle after a certain (small) codebase size.

I'm interested to hear whether Claude Code writes less brittle code, or how you use it/what your experience with it is.

vidarh1y ago

I tested Aider a few times, and gave up because at the time it was so bad - it might be time to try it again, and I'll add that my experience with seeing how Claude Code works for me while lots of other people struggle with it suggests to me that my experience with Aider might well be that my style of working just meshes better with Claude Code than Aider.

Claude Code was the first assistant that gelled for me, and I use it daily. It wrote the first pass of multi-monitor support for my window manager. It's written the last several commits of my Ruby X11 bindings, including a working systray example, where it both suggested the whole approach and implemented it, and tested it with me just acting as a clicking monkey (because I haven't set up any tooling to let it interact with the GUI) when it ran test scripts.

I think you just needs to test the two side by side and see what works for you.

I intend to give Aider a go at some point again, as I would love to use an open source tool for this, but ultimately I'll use the one that produces better results for me.

stavros1y ago

Makes sense, thanks. I've used Claude Code but it goes off on its own too much, whereas Aider is more focused. If you do give Aider another shot, use the architect/editor mode, with Gemini 2.5 Pro and Claude 3.7, respectively. It's produced the best results for me.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse

0 comments

stavros1y ago

I'm interested to hear whether Claude Code writes less brittle code, or how you use it/what your experience with it is.

vidarh1y ago

I think you just needs to test the two side by side and see what works for you.

I intend to give Aider a go at some point again, as I would love to use an open source tool for this, but ultimately I'll use the one that produces better results for me.

stavros1y ago

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse