undefined | Better HN

0 pointsXenophileJKO10mo ago0 comments

:) I'll bite...

For bonus points.. the tail-less crocodile.. https://chatgpt.com/s/m_6815c29c1bf081918c791447441c400e

You just lack imagination, like I said.. there are almost no limits but pixel density and aspect ratio currently.

0 comments

otabdeveloper410mo ago

You're not making art, you're running prompts through a meme picture generator.

Like I said, you know nothing about making art. (Not a big deal, not everybody needs to.)

In an alternative parallel universe we might have gotten actual AI tools for making art - these would be various infilling plugins, basically. ("Make me a Photoshop brush that paints pine-needle looking spiky things", that sort of thing.)

What we got in this reality is not that, though. Meme making of the sort you posted is not art.

(That said, making memes, especially of the spicy and/or topical kind, is the one niche that generative AI is good at and nails perfectly.)

ranger_danger10mo ago

Arguing about what "art" is is a tale as old as time, relax. Your own perspective is not the only valid one that can exist.

XenophileJKOOP10mo ago

I mean I did have a meme or two in there to show the range. You clearly didn't look at it if you think it is all memes. Maybe think hard about what art really is.. a brush is a brush..

I don't have to justify my art to anyone. The magic is.. you can't choose what is art. You can choose what YOU think is art and that's fine. However you can't dictate to the world what is art.

x0xrx10mo ago

I agree you don’t have to justify your art. But which was not a meme? I clicked many and found only memes.

idonotknowwhy10mo ago

That's not the AI creating art though, that's you using 4o like a pencil. The ideas / creativity came from you, not the AI.

P.S. Do you mind sharing the prompt you used to do the crocodile?

XenophileJKOOP10mo ago

Sure... I mean it isn't a single prompt.. it is always a process.

https://chatgpt.com/share/681855ce-a9d4-8004-9a3a-deb19994d8...

Edit: I was really just testing to see how well it could do layout and out of distrobution images. This was right when it came out and I was trying to see what the limitations were.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse

0 comments

otabdeveloper410mo ago

You're not making art, you're running prompts through a meme picture generator.

Like I said, you know nothing about making art. (Not a big deal, not everybody needs to.)

What we got in this reality is not that, though. Meme making of the sort you posted is not art.

(That said, making memes, especially of the spicy and/or topical kind, is the one niche that generative AI is good at and nails perfectly.)

ranger_danger10mo ago

Arguing about what "art" is is a tale as old as time, relax. Your own perspective is not the only valid one that can exist.

XenophileJKOOP10mo ago

I mean I did have a meme or two in there to show the range. You clearly didn't look at it if you think it is all memes. Maybe think hard about what art really is.. a brush is a brush..

I don't have to justify my art to anyone. The magic is.. you can't choose what is art. You can choose what YOU think is art and that's fine. However you can't dictate to the world what is art.

x0xrx10mo ago

I agree you don’t have to justify your art. But which was not a meme? I clicked many and found only memes.

idonotknowwhy10mo ago

That's not the AI creating art though, that's you using 4o like a pencil. The ideas / creativity came from you, not the AI.

P.S. Do you mind sharing the prompt you used to do the crocodile?

XenophileJKOOP10mo ago

Sure... I mean it isn't a single prompt.. it is always a process.

https://chatgpt.com/share/681855ce-a9d4-8004-9a3a-deb19994d8...

Edit: I was really just testing to see how well it could do layout and out of distrobution images. This was right when it came out and I was trying to see what the limitations were.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse