undefined | Better HN

0 pointsdefrost11mo ago0 comments

The video doesn't disprove a long standing non Christian association between what is now Easter and rabbits.

What it does state is in agreement with the wikipedia article on the connection between Ēostre and rabbits, namely:

  The earliest evidence for the Easter Hare (Osterhase) was recorded in south-west Germany in 1678 by the professor of medicine Georg Franck von Franckenau

~ https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/%C4%92ostre

This is the earliest still extant written account of folk practices that had been occurring for some indeterminant time.

We are aware that the brewing of beer predates by many centuries, millenia even, the earliest still extant written account of the practice of brewing beer.

0 comments

suddenlybananas11mo ago

Of course it is possible that the tradition goes back more than a thousand years from when it was first attested, but we have no material evidence of that whatsoever. No statues of a goddess surrounded by eggs and rabbits, no amulets of protection, no recorded myths, no references to something similar from Greek or Roman sources, nothing. This is in contrast to beer where we have actually found remains of beer from long, long ago.

defrostOP11mo ago

It certainly existed for generations prior to when it was first written about .. as much of all human activity did.

We have actual remains of rabbits from long long ago.

The point being much human activity leaves little trace, we'd be wise to not assume the only human activity was activity that left a pyramid or giant stautue in its wake.

suddenlybananas11mo ago

Yes, but traditions are also invented all the time, and there's no reason to assume a random tradition among German Protestants in the 17th century goes back over a thousand years without evidence.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse

0 pointsdefrost11mo ago0 comments

The video doesn't disprove a long standing non Christian association between what is now Easter and rabbits.

What it does state is in agreement with the wikipedia article on the connection between Ēostre and rabbits, namely:

  The earliest evidence for the Easter Hare (Osterhase) was recorded in south-west Germany in 1678 by the professor of medicine Georg Franck von Franckenau

~ https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/%C4%92ostre

This is the earliest still extant written account of folk practices that had been occurring for some indeterminant time.

We are aware that the brewing of beer predates by many centuries, millenia even, the earliest still extant written account of the practice of brewing beer.

0 comments

suddenlybananas11mo ago

defrostOP11mo ago

It certainly existed for generations prior to when it was first written about .. as much of all human activity did.

We have actual remains of rabbits from long long ago.

The point being much human activity leaves little trace, we'd be wise to not assume the only human activity was activity that left a pyramid or giant stautue in its wake.

suddenlybananas11mo ago

Yes, but traditions are also invented all the time, and there's no reason to assume a random tradition among German Protestants in the 17th century goes back over a thousand years without evidence.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse