undefined | Better HN

0 pointsglobular-toast1y ago0 comments

SQLAlchemy Session is actually a unit of work (UoW), which they also build on top. By the end of the book they are using their UoW to collect and dispatch events emitted by the services. How would they have done that if they just used SQLAlchemy directly?

You might argue that they should have waited until they wanted their own UoW behaviour before actually implementing it, but that means by the time they need it they need to go and modify potentially hundreds of bits of calling code to swap out SQLAlchemy for their own wrapper. Why not just build it first? The worst that happens is it sits there being mostly redundant. There have been far worse things.

The tricks you mention for the tests might work for SQLAlchemy, but what if we're not using SQLAlchemy? The repository pattern works for everything. That's what makes it a pattern.

0 comments

bulatb1y ago

I understand not everyone agrees on what "repository" means. The session is a UoW (at two or three levels) and also a repository (in the sense of object-scoped persistence) and also like four other things.

I'm sort of tolerant of bits of Session leaking into things. I'd argue that its leaking pieces are the application-level things you'd implement, not versions of them from the lower layers that you need to wrap.

When users filter data and their filters go from POST submissions to some high-level Filter thing I'd pass to a repository query, what does that construct look like? Pretty much Query.filter(). When I pick how many things I want from the repository, it's Query.first() or Query.one(), or Query.filter().filter().filter().all().

Yes, it's tied to SQL, but only in a literal sense. The API would look like that no matter what, even if it wasn't. When the benefit outweighs the cost, I choose to treat it like it is the thing I should have written.

It isn't ideal or ideally correct, but it's fine, and it's simple.

globular-toastOP1y ago

You seem to have stopped reading my comment after the first sentence. I asked some specific questions about how you would do what they did if you just use SQLAlchemy as your repository/UoW.

yahoozoo1y ago

You do that in your services.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse