undefined | Better HN

0 pointsJoshTriplett1y ago0 comments

I'm well aware of the cost difference, but the cost of internal-only functions is potentially measured in antitrust actions.

Microsoft, post-antitrust action, made a very careful point of ensuring new functionality in first-party products like Office only used things that had public APIs.

0 comments

shuckles1y ago

Yeah it does seem like antitrust is the wedge employed by 3rd parties who would like Apple to do free R&D for them, most ironically by Spotify which holds are arguable monopoly on music streaming.

I’m glad that antitrust enabled a rich ecosystem of Microsoft Office alternatives and competitors.

JoshTriplettOP1y ago

Apple certainly doesn't have to do free R&D for third parties. They could, instead, not ship features that work exclusively with other Apple products. Or, hey, there's also the other valid option of "don't be the exclusive gatekeeper of the platform", they're welcome to take that one too.

When Apple goes up against governments over encryption, I'll cheer them on with everyone else. When Apple is engaging in https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tying_(commerce) , I have zero sympathy for them.

shuckles1y ago

You are at least an honest critic here in that you admit you'd rather Apple not build great features for its own customers if that means some hypothetical future company isn't allowed to hypothetically build its own version if Apple made some or all of its proprietary R&D available for free to this hypothetical competitor.

Most people pretend that all that effort is free and trivial to expose as API.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse

0 pointsJoshTriplett1y ago0 comments

I'm well aware of the cost difference, but the cost of internal-only functions is potentially measured in antitrust actions.

Microsoft, post-antitrust action, made a very careful point of ensuring new functionality in first-party products like Office only used things that had public APIs.

0 comments

shuckles1y ago

Yeah it does seem like antitrust is the wedge employed by 3rd parties who would like Apple to do free R&D for them, most ironically by Spotify which holds are arguable monopoly on music streaming.

I’m glad that antitrust enabled a rich ecosystem of Microsoft Office alternatives and competitors.

JoshTriplettOP1y ago

shuckles1y ago

Most people pretend that all that effort is free and trivial to expose as API.

j / k navigate · click thread line to collapse